Robert Knight: Santa Fe, Ichetucknee suffering death by a thousand cuts

bobknights article May In: Robert Knight: Santa Fe, Ichetucknee suffering death by a thousand cuts | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River*

This is serious stuff, this is the truth being told to the people who have the obligation to listen and do their jobs.

Our springs and rivers are dying and those who are supposed to protect them are dancing and waffling here and there and missing the main target.  Some of those who are supposed to lead have no clue that we have water problems.

OSFR’s Merrillee Malwitz-Jipson and other members for years have been requesting a cessation of withdrawal permits until the springs and the Santa Fe have been restored.

As Dr. Knight was unable to attend the May 14 meeting he mentions, Lucinda Merrit of the Icheteucknee Alliance read to the board a letter expressing his thoughts expressed here.

Near the end of the meeting for about 40 minutes, Mike Roth, Lu Merritt, John Quarterman, Mike Kern and your historian all spoke to the board frankly about the seriousness of our water situation.  Several board members exhibited an astonishing naїveté regarding nitrate pollution, indicating they believed that agriculture played a minor role.  Another member thought the springs were in good health  (see our post “SRWMD Hears Words of Truth”, and these videos from Suwannee RiverKeeper John Quarterman posting in WWALS.)

It is not surprising the Suwannee River Water Management Board continues to approve huge water withdrawals if they actually believe this does not affect our springs and rivers.  Nearly impossible to believe, but it appears so.

But indeed the staff know better, and it is their duty to educate the board.  We can hope the SRWMD people along with the Secretary of Florida Department of Environmental Protection all read this excellent article.

You can read it online here in the Gainesville Sun.  Look for the hard copy in Sunday’s edition.

Comments by OSFR historian Jim Tatum.
-A river is like a life: once taken, it cannot be brought back-

Robert Knight: Santa Fe, Ichetucknee suffering death by a thousand cuts

Posted at 2:00 AM

Recently as I was reading The Sun, a small note on the classified page shouted out to me: “Public Notice – The Suwannee River Water Management District (District) intends to issue a Water Use Permit for a maximum of 150,000 gallons per day in Alachua County for row crops and cattle watering. Affected parties can obtain a copy of the Technical Staff Report by writing the District.”

Having recently compiled a list of well permits issued over the past four years, I was acutely aware of the district’s unrelenting approval of water-use permits and the detrimental impact of those groundwater withdrawals on our area’s springs.

In 2014 the district completed a multi-year study of the Santa Fe and Ichetucknee rivers and concluded that both waterways were beyond the point of significant harm due to excessive groundwater pumping. In 2015 the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, in association with the district, implemented a prevention and recovery strategy to comply with the Santa Fe and Ichetucknee minimum flow requirements.

DEP also adopted a water quality action plan in 2012 for the same two rivers. That plan requires a 50% reduction in nitrogen fertilizer loading, or 3.6 million pounds of nitrogen per year for the 1,800-square-mile Santa Fe springshed, the area that recharges the aquifer and provides water to the more than 50 springs that flow into these rivers.

A logical approach to correcting the water quantity and quality crisis on the Santa Fe/Ichetucknee rivers is to set a safe limit or cap on groundwater use permits. Every well permit that allows more groundwater to be withdrawn from the aquifer also facilitates the application of more fertilizer to agricultural fields or lawns. The resulting depletion and pollution of our region’s groundwater is a double cut to the health of our drinking water and local springs.

In the Santa Fe springshed, 2,100 new well permits have been issued since 2015 when the district and DEP acknowledged significant harm had already occurred to the area’s springs and rivers. Four years ago, the environmental agencies assured the public that we had entered a “prevention and recovery” period for these water bodies.

But based on district estimates, the new well permits collectively authorize an additional 10 billion gallons of groundwater extraction over the next 20 years. Based on typical water and fertilizer use rates in the Santa Fe springshed, those permitted uses will also contribute an estimated 65,000 pounds of additional nitrate nitrogen to the waters of the Santa Fe River.

Last month the Florida Springs Institute sent a letter to the district with this information and requested rejection of the proposed permit. The Alachua County Commission was also contacted by the institute with the request that commissioners take a strong stand to object to the state’s continuing disregard for the health and future of the Santa Fe River and her springs.

Three local advocates for the Santa Fe and Ichetucknee rivers attended the district’s board meeting on May 14 and spoke against issuance of this new water use permit and all subsequent water use permits that will further harm the area’s water resources. Nevertheless, the district’s governing board issued the permit.

Unfortunately for county residents who enjoy these rivers and springs, county commissioners took no action to oppose this permit.

The science is clear — the aesthetic and economic health of our local rivers and springs is being stolen as groundwater withdrawals and fertilizer inputs increase, one gallon and one pound at a time.

A line must be drawn in the sand: No new wells should be permitted until a greater volume of existing groundwater use is reduced or revoked. The best way to curb excessive groundwater extraction is to meter all uses and to charge fees so this precious resource will not be wasted. Florida’s local governmental leaders need to join forces and take this message to state legislators.

The springs that provide more than 80% of the flow of the Santa Fe and Ichetucknee rivers are suffering from “death by a thousand cuts.” It is past time to stop this senseless destruction of our region’s natural resources and heritage.

Robert Knight is the director of the Howard T. Odum Florida Springs Institute. Visit the group at the North Florida Springs Environmental Center in High Springs.

*Photo from Sun files.  Paddler on the Santa Fe River.

1 Comment

  1. to Jim Tatum:
    mike kern Visited Gilchrist Co. records dept. last week to inquire if any plans have been submitted to the county for Rock Bluff Springs development. No, plans have been submitted by SRWMD or ACT for Rock Bluff Spring. He was told that the water bottling plant, once owned by Coca cola, which was sold and closed has now been recently purchased again and is seeking permits by SRWMD to re-open the water bottling plant, near Ginny Springs. Did you know this? The permit dept. in Gilchrist Co. said this was a recent event, and this company is applying for a large water withdraw. SRWMD is failing to govern their charge. The board is in conflict with water conservation. The Director and his assistant directors have little power to object to anything the board wants to do. I suggest the Environmental groups gather to petition for a new independent board without ties to the boards own interests. I believe the only way is to oust our current board members. Keep a journal of conflicts of interest. Two new opening are on the Board of Directors for SRWMD. Find someone who can apply who is interested in water conservation. Then support them all the way to the Governor. With all the good smart people I have met who believe in water conservation, you can find a great person.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
Skip to content