DEP Secretary Valenstein resigns

image_print

 

merrillee-valenstein2
OSFR’s Merrillee Malwitz-Jipson with Valenstein at the latter’s first regular meeting as head of SRWMD. OSFR had several ties with Valenstein over the years. Photo by Jim Tatum.

 

cris costello c In: DEP Secretary Valenstein resigns | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River in North Florida
Cris Costello, a true environmentalist

“Anything positive he [Valenstein] may have done over the years has been completely overshadowed by his insistence on greenwashing governors DeSantis and Scott. We need a secretary who will protect the environment, not the governor,” said Cris Costello, senior organizing manager for Sierra Florida, in a message to the Phoenix.

 

There has been praise for Valenstein from some environmental leaders as his resignation is announced.  In order to evaluate his work, we should ask this question – is Florida’s environment better or worse after his tenure?

Yes, now we have a Blue-Green Algae Task Force and a Chief Science Officer, but what have they accomplished except spend money and come up with political answers?

Do we have less red tide and algae?  Is the Santa Fe River flowing stronger?  Does it have fewer nitrates?  Are MFLs stronger for the Rainbow and other iconic Florida rivers?  Is the restoration of our impaired rivers and springs progressing satisfactorily?  Anyone who has kept up with current activities among environmentalists and the authorities governing water (agencies and lawmakers) knows the answers.

The amount of money spent is not a criterion in evaluating the efficacy of environmental work.

The reps from the Nature Conservancy, the Everglades Foundation and Audubon should ask these questions before fawning over politicians.

Read the original article here in Florida Phoenix.

Comments by OSFR historian Jim Tatum.
[email protected]
– A river is like a life: once taken,
it cannot be brought back © Jim Tatum


DEP Secretary Valenstein resigns; says he will continue to work in ‘environmental community’

Noah Valenstein, secretary of Florida’s Department of Environmental Protection, announced his resignation Thursday, effective on Friday, June 4.

Gov. Ron DeSantis’ office acknowledged late Thursday Valenstein submitted his letter of resignation on May 8 but did not make it public until he notified department employees earlier Thursday.

He has worked at DEP since the administration of former Gov. Rick Scott and has served as secretary since 2017.

DEP Secretary Noah Valenstein 0 In: DEP Secretary Valenstein resigns | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River in North Florida
Noah Valenstein

Valenstein wrote in a letter he addressed to his “team” Thursday that Shawn Hamilton will succeed him as interim secretary of the department. Hamilton is deputy secretary over the Division of Land and Recreation, which manages state parks and the Florida Forever land-conservation program. Hamilton has been with DEP for 13 years.

“With the new agency framework completed and the largest environmental budget in the state’s history secured, it is time for me to step back and DEP to move forward with implementation under a new leader,” Valenstein wrote.

shawn hamilton In: DEP Secretary Valenstein resigns | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River in North Florida
Shawn Hamilton

Valenstein said in the internal letter that he intends to “carry on my passion for the environment in the environmental community.” He provided no details.

In his May 8 letter to the governor, Valenstein wrote in part, “DEP and our partners have expedited critical Everglades restoration projects, employed sound science to protect and restore our waterways, funded infrastructure projects to improve our state’s coastal resiliency to climate change, acquired lands through Florida Forever to safeguard Florida’s critical water supply and provided resource-based recreation to residents and visitors.

“The Blue-Green Algae Task Force was created, and our state now has a Chief Science Officer for the very first time. We also saw the naming of the first statewide Chief Resilience Officer, a role I was pleased to take on. These actions laid out a critical foundation for science-driven environmental policy to ensure success through strategic investments in the right projects and initiatives.

“We also worked together to secure the unanimous passage of SB 712, the Clean Waterways Act, landmark legislation that contains a wide range of water quality protection provisions aimed at minimizing the impacts of nutrient pollution that can cause harmful algal blooms. The legislation also proved that seemingly disparate stakeholders can work together for the betterment of Florida’s environment. House Bill 1091, which also passed the Florida Legislature unanimously, was also signed into law, which increased penalties for sanitary sewer overflows by 100 percent and all other environmental penalties by 50 percent.”

Environmental organizations  had high hopes early on that DeSantis would empower Valenstein to do much more for Florida’s environment than was possible under Gov. Scott. Some were disappointed.

“Inasmuch as part of his tenure involved working in the Scott administration, perhaps his biggest accomplishment was preventing the department from completely devolving into a mere shell of its former self,” said Jerry Phillips, director of Florida Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, or PEER, in a message to the Phoenix.

“That said, we have not seen significant improvement in the department under Governor DeSantis. Were it not for a handful of major cases apparently designed to present the secretary and governor in a good light, environmental enforcement in Florida has seen only modest improvement and is still far from being effective.”

Sierra Club of Florida said DeSantis does not deserve to claim he is an “environmental” governor and accuses his senior staff of “greenwashing” his record.

“Anything positive he [Valenstein] may have done over the years has been completely overshadowed by his insistence on greenwashing governors DeSantis and Scott. We need a secretary who will protect the environment, not the governor,” said Cris Costello, senior organizing manager for Sierra Florida, in a message to the Phoenix.

DEP’s communications office released these comments it gathered from three other organizations.

“Few people are as experienced in Florida environmental policy and as focused on restoring America’s Everglades as Noah Valenstein,” said Eric Eikenberg, CEO of the Everglades Foundation, where Valenstein once served as director of legislative affairs. “Under the leadership of Governor Ron DeSantis, he presided over a period of historic activity by the DEP to help steer a number of long-overdue projects toward completion that, once operational, will cut algae-causing discharges and nurture the Everglades and Florida Bay.”

“Secretary Valenstein’s commitment to science and his public policy sophistication breathed new life into DEP, reinforcing the importance of its public servants to Florida’s quality of life and prosperity,” wrote Julie Wraithmell, executive director of Audubon Florida.

“Florida has been well-served with his initiatives and guidance,” said Temperince Morgan, executive director of the Nature Conservancy in Florida.

Columnist Craig Pittman contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
Skip to content