The Case for Rights of Nature—


nature 1 In: The Case for Rights of Nature--- | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River

When it comes to pictures of springs, no one does it better than John Moran and his new photo essay tells a powerful story that words cannot adequately describe.

Somewhere in the Florida Statutes it says we have the right to clean air and water but we all know that those who make the rules ignore this in favor of allowing the pollution of our water and the destruction of our springs if it gets in the way of some company wanting to make more money.

JohnMoran In: The Case for Rights of Nature--- | Our Santa Fe River, Inc. (OSFR) | Protecting the Santa Fe River
John Moran. Photo by Jim Tatum.

Rep. Chuck Clemons’ brazenly false statement below is but one of many coming from our political leaders, including  the Secretary of Florida Department of Environmental Protection, not just the current secretary, but also several of those preceding him.  These statements are insulting because anyone with a minimum of powers of observation can see that we are fast losing our springs and rivers.  We do not need the false science that  our water management districts use in order to know that our water resources are dying under their watch, even though they tell us the opposite.

If Floridians want the truth about our water, one must go NOT  to those whose job it is to protect it, but to grass roots organizations and individuals like John Moran, Merrillee Malwitz-Jipson, Lisa Rinaman, John Quarterman, Bob Knight, the late Whitey Markle and many others, none of whom is on a state payroll.

Our thanks go to John Moran for permission to republish this work in its entirety.

Please go to this link on the SAFEBOR website to see the complete photo essay.

Comments by OSFR historian Jim Tatum.
– A river is like a life: once taken,
it cannot be brought back © Jim Tatum

The case for Rights of Nature: Next steps for the SAFEBOR campaign


By John Moran  March 2020

It’s a fair question: With the passage of the heralded Clean Waterways Act of 2020, why is the SAFEBOR campaign still pushing for a Bill of Rights for the Santa Fe River?

Here’s a hint: despite the bill’s catchy title, Tallahassee isn’t coming to the rescue.

Looking under the hood, this bill does nothing to reduce the dominant source of pollution ravaging our beloved rivers and springs.

How can this be? Here’s another hint: Follow the money. With the support of nearly every major polluting industry in Florida, the legislature has once again prioritized polluter profits over protecting public waters.

But wait, there’s more: SB712 also preempts local government anywhere in Florida from recognizing Rights of Nature.

So how did we get here?

Rivers ebb and rivers flow but Denial still reigns as the mightiest river in Florida.

Consider the bizarre pronouncement from Rep. Chuck Clemons last year in the wake of the worst water crisis in state history, Florida’s infamous 2018 Summer of Slime.

Clemons boldly stated in a Gainesville Sun opinion column, “Florida’s environment is getting better. Much better. And that is directly tied to the leadership of Florida.”

Incredulous, I grabbed my cameras and went to more than a dozen springs on the Santa Fe and Suwannee Rivers last summer; searching for evidence that our springs really are getting better.

I found no cause for celebration. The pictures below tell the tale. What I found broke my heart and pissed me off. In almost every spring in the Suwannee River Valley, disgusting and noxious slime—fueled largely by agricultural fertilizer and manure—is now the dominant life form. The new normal.

The most magnificent natural springs on the planet are becoming aquatic wastelands. They’re dying on our watch.

We were told 2020 was going to be the year that Tallahassee ditched the blinders and embraced clear vision. Instead we got legislative malfeasance masquerading as responsible oversight.

This legislature didn’t formally declare war on clean water in Florida but it begs the question, could the condition of our springs be much worse if they had?

The governor could veto this defective bill but don’t hold your breath. In the words of the director of one of Florida’s leading environmental nonprofits, “Agriculture gets a free pass to pollute and Ron DeSantis is Rick Scott with a new coat of paint.”

So what’s the status of the SAFEBOR campaign now?

With voter approval in November, Alachua County’s Home Rule Charter will be amended to recognize the right of the Santa Fe River to naturally exist and flourish and to assert our community’s right to a healthy river ecosystem and aquifer.

More than 4000 voters signed our petition to place a Rights of Nature initiative on the ballot but that was well short of the required 18,094 signatures, so now it’s on to Plan B.

We’ve appealed to the Charter Review Commission and the Board of County Commissioners—the public can weigh in, too—to directly place Rights of Nature on the ballot despite the looming threat of legislative preemption.

With their own attorneys advising against it, why should the CRC or BoCC tangle with Tallahassee and risk an expensive lawsuit?

Simply put, Florida’s water is Florida’s lifeblood. And our waters are under siege. Job One for government, it bears repeating, is to foster public health, safety and welfare.

But an epidemic of indifference has swept through the Capitol, fueled by an ideological cocktail of power, hubris and greed.

In the fever grip of plunder consciousness, our legislators have tested positive for dishonoring the intelligence of nature and the will of the people. They have defiled democracy itself.

We’re heading for a cliff and Tallahassee’s message is clear: We’re not going to fix this and neither are you. Rights of Nature isn’t new and it’s not radical. Ancient wisdom is speaking, if only we will listen. The self-evident truth is that we need nature more than nature needs us.

It’s time for deep, systemic change. This moment demands brave political leaders who understand that Rights of Nature is an idea whose time has come.

Let the voters decide. And if voters approve then let’s vigorously defend our County Charter and challenge Tallahassee’s outrageous claim that we have no right to clean water and healthy communities.

Will Rights of Nature save the river? Perhaps the bigger question is this: Can Rights of Nature save us from ourselves? A Bill of Rights for the river is a Bill of Rights for the future. It’s the right thing to do.


John Moran is a Gainesville-based nature photographer and water advocate.


  1. Protecting Nature heals our spirits. Exploiting Nature diminishes our self esteem. Be kind, be brave. Speak out for Mother Nature!<

  2. The best thing to do is to keep writing our so called leaders and then vote DeSantos out and Clemons out and the others that won’t get on board to Safebor. I remember the springs as they were 40 years ago. Now They are disgustingly polluted. s
    Send buckets of slime to De Santos and to Clemons daily. Ill pay the postage.
    VOTE THEM OUT. DeSantos promised but LIED. HE is a Scott with hair.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
Skip to content