The following is a press release from the First Amendment Foundation calling for a halt to the M-CORES virtual meetings alleging they violate the Florida Sunshine Law. The toll roads are an ill-conceived plan for a few people to get rich and are absolutely not needed. In this time of economical crisis, the toll roads are the last thing we should be thinking about.
The development that would accompany the toll roads would take Florida to a fatal step downward from which we would never recover. Our water supply projections show that we will not have enough potable water for the people who are already here. The Florida Department of Environmental Protection and our five water management districts and even our judges have allowed and continue to allow constant degradation of our water by pollution and over-pumping. It is the norm and protocol in Florida and this must stop. We must drastically change our attitude toward our water resources and begin by treating it like the valuable resource it is.
Florida is in the Dark Ages of water management.
Comments by OSFR historian Jim Tatum.
jim.tatum@oursantaferiver.org
– A river is like a life: once taken,
it cannot be brought back © Jim Tatum
———- Forwarded message ———
From: Pamela C Marsh <pmarsh@floridafaf.org>
Date: Thu, May 28, 2020 at 5:20 PM
Subject: PRESS RELEASE: First Amendment Foundation calls for halt to virtual M-CORES Task Force Meetings
To: info <info@floridafaf.org>
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
May 28, 20220
Contact: Pamela Marsh, 850.224.4555, pmarsh@floridafaf.org
**PRESS RELEASE**
FIRST AMENDMENT FOUNDATION TO FDOT:
Stop Conducting Virtual M-CORES Task Force Meetings in Violation of the Law
TALLAHASSEE—Today the First Amendment Foundation (FAF) addressed the Florida Department of Transportation’s failure to follow the law with respect to its virtual M-CORES Task Force meetings in April and May in a letter to Kevin J. Thibault, Secretary of the Florida Department of Transportation:
May 28, 2020
Mr. Kevin J. Thibault
Secretary of the Florida Department of Transportation
605 Suwannee Street
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0450
Via email to kevin.thibault@dot.state.fl.us
RE: M-CORES Task Force Webinars
Dear Secretary Thibault:
I write on behalf of the First Amendment Foundation to bring your attention to the unfortunate exclusion of persons wishing to participate in M-CORES Task Force meetings, now being held by webinar. The webinars are a poor substitute for the kind of government that is required by Florida’s Sunshine Law, which does apply to the M-CORES Task Force meetings. I appreciate that in adopting this process, your agency was attempting to keep citizens safe during a pandemic. Now, however, as Florida begins to fully re-open, the First Amendment Foundation requests that all M-CORES Task Force meeting webinars immediately be postponed (and preferably canceled) until “all interested persons” can be accommodated pursuant to law.
As you know, Executive Order 20-69 (as extended by Executive Order 20-114) applies only to local governments and does not apply to agencies or any decision-making and/or advisory board or committee created by a state agency.
FDOT is subject to the provisions of §120.54(5), Fla. Stat., and the rules authorized by that section. In addition, §338.2278, Fla. Stat., sets forth the law on Multiuse Corridors of Regional Economic Significance (M-CORES) and specifically states: “Each corridor task force shall hold a public meeting in accordance with chapter 286 in each local government jurisdiction in which a project within an identified corridor is being considered.” Fla. Stat., §338.2278(3)(c)5 (emphasis added). And, as you know Chapter 286 provides the parameters and application of Florida’s Government-in-the-Sunshine Law.
Further, Florida Administrative Code Rule 28-109.004 specifically applies the Sunshine Law to all proceedings conducted by state agencies, including the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT). Specifically, Rule 28-109.004 provides:
(1) Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to permit the agency to conduct any proceeding otherwise subject to the provisions of Section 286.011, F.S., exclusively by means of CMT without making provision for the attendance of any member of the public who desires to attend.
and
(2) No proceeding otherwise subject to Section 286.011, F.S., shall be conducted exclusively by means of CMT if the available technology is insufficient to permit all interested persons to attend.
Fla. Admin. Code Rule 28-109.004.
The rule goes on to state that “[i]f during the course of a CMT proceeding technical problems develop with the communications network that prevent interested persons from attending, the agency shall terminate the proceeding until the problems have been corrected.” Id. (emphasis added). However, FDOT has already completed at least six M-CORES virtual Task Force meetings on April 28, 29, and 30 and on May 12, 13, and 14 (see https://floridamcores.com/calendar-of-events/) during which obvious and undeniable webinar technical and access failures occurred. At none of these meetings did FDOT terminate the proceedings as required by law. Rather, FDOT proceeded with its virtual-only approach, despite technical failures during each of those six webinars.
In short, all of these six meeting have been conducted in violation of the law applying to and establishing M-CORES, and by so doing FDOT is also in violation of Florida’s Sunshine Law. Until FDOT can provide access to “all interested persons” it cannot proceed without further violating Florida law.
The M-CORES task force is required by statute to deliver their evaluation in a final report to the Governor, the President of the Senate and the Speaker of the House. See Fla. Stat. § 338.2278(3)(c)9 (2019). As a result, there is no question that the M-CORES task force exercises the “type of advisory capacity that would be subject to the provisions of the government in the sunshine law.” Town of Palm Beach v. Gradison, 296 So. 2d 473, 476 (Fla. 1974).
If FDOT continues to hold M-CORES task force meetings by virtual “webinar meeting” and members of the public are unable to get online or call in to participate, the meeting must be terminated pursuant to Fla. Admin. Code Rule 28-109.004(2) and the law cited in this letter. Otherwise, FDOT is in violation of Florida law.
All portions of the Sunshine Law continue to apply even during this horrible pandemic. No part of the Law has been suspended or modified as applied to state agencies. As a result, I respectfully request that FDOT exercise patience, cancel any and all M-CORES Task Force meetings, and reschedule the meetings only when members of the Task Force and Florida citizens can fully participate in-person and by all feasible means.
With best regards,
Pamela C. Marsh
President
cc: William N. Watts Jr.
Huiwei Shen
Letter: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1efez3x7PhBTgRmAwihPg5EyZEMpydb8K/view?usp=sharing
Pamela C. Marsh, President
850.224.4555
800.337.3518 (Toll-Free Hotline)
317 E. Park Avenue
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
If you value the work we do, please become a member or give a gift today. We can only do more to protect your rights with your support.
###
